Departmental Support


CTLE Critical Teaching Behaviors (CTB) Presentation Handouts

CTLE Critical Teaching Behaviors (CTB) Presentation Slides

Writing About Teaching: Tips and Best Practices for Writing Faculty Evaluations (R&R Letters)


Critical Teaching Behaviors (CTB) and Peer Observations

Effective Fall 2026, the Office of Faculty Affairs has instituted a new policy stating that departments and chairs may no longer rely solely on student course evaluations when making employment-related decisions about teaching. The CTLE recommends using the Critical Teaching Behaviors (CTB) framework, based on the groundbreaking book Critical Teaching Behaviors: Defining, Documenting, and Discussing Good Teaching (Stylus, 2023) by Lauren Barbeau and Claudia Cornejo Happel, for identifying and documenting multiple sources and varied evidence of effective teaching. Additionally, CTB is a clear and widely applicable framework for departments who want to conduct thoughtful, strengths-based, and equity-minded peer observations of teaching. CTLE Director Jessamyn Neuhaus would be glad to come to your department, school, or college to give a short overview of the CTB approach, facilitate a discussion or workshop ideas about peer observations in your department, or consult with your department about how to collect, define, and maximize different types of evidence for documenting effective teaching.


Pedagogy Pitstops

A Pedagogy Pitstop is a short (10 minute or less), fast-paced presentation on a specific, high-impact, evidence-based teaching practice. It includes several immediately applicable teaching takeaways for faculty. The CTLE brings the Pedagogy Pitstop directly to you, and will present it during any regularly scheduled department (or program, school, or college) meeting. We currently offer the following Pedagogy Pitstop presentations:

  • Interactive Lecturing
  • Creating Connections with a Class Directory and First-Day Survey
  • Three Ways to Encourage Academically Honest Use of Generative AI
  • Structuring Successful Student Group Projects
  • Why Your Students Need a Midsemester Class Grade

CTLE Services Spotlight

A CTLE Services Spotlight is a short (10 minutes or less) overview of a programmatic or on-demand service that the CTLE provides to individual faculty, departments, programs, schools, or colleges. It includes registration links and other related information. We will bring the Services Spotlight to you during your regularly scheduled department (or program, school, or college) meeting. We currently offer the following Service Spotlight presentations:

  • How the CTLE Can Help You Document Your Teaching Growth Narrative
  • Improving Teaching Observations/Peer Teaching Reviews
  • Pro Tips for Applying to the CTLE’s Annual Course Redesign Institute (CRI)
  • Students Consulting on Teaching (SCOT) for Early Course Feedback
  • Using the CTLE’s Online Curated Collections of Teaching Resources

Workshops for Departments

We are happy to schedule a session of any previously offered CTLE workshop, and bring it to your department via Zoom or in-person in your building or at 550 Bird Library (CTLE). Our current workshop offerings include:

  • AI Usage Statement and Citations in Teaching and Learning
  • Assignments and Assessments in the Age of Generative AI
  • Classroom Phone/Device Policies
  • Co-Creating Classroom Community Agreements
  • The Critical Teaching Behaviors Framework for Evaluating Teaching
  • Fun to Grade and AI Outsourcing-Resistant: The Unessay
  • Increasing Student Learning During Class and in Assignments
  • Keep Your Teaching Batteries Charged
  • Learning Student Names
  • Planning for Learner Variability
  • Reflective Practices for Crafting a Growth Narrative and Mitigating Burnout
  • Supporting Student Success with Productive Error Course Design
  • Teaching in Tumultuous Times: The Value of Scripts
  • Teach with Your Strengths
  • A Welcoming Syllabus

Department Consultations

The CTLE is available for consultations with Chairs, department leaders and committees, and/or the whole department on any aspect of teaching and learning. Our goal as a thought partner and facilitator is to help your department have productive, positive discussions about pedagogy and classroom strategies, and to provide you with resources as requested in order to support your department members’ discipline-based pedagogical expertise and teaching practices.

For the 2026-2027 academic year, our MP Faculty Fellows are also available to consult with departments. Mark Brockway, Assistant Teaching Professor of Political Science, focuses on  easy-to-implement active learning classroom activities, syllabus design, and student wellness. Zach Huitink, Associate Teaching Professor and a Birkhead-Burkhead Professor of Teaching Excellence in the Department of Public Administration and International Affairs, is an expert in course design and effective teaching in online asynchronous environments, and Doug Yung, Teaching Professor of Biomedical and Chemical Engineering is studying and facilitating pedagogical reflection on AI in teaching and learning.


Contact Us

If you would like to schedule a Pedagogy Pitstop or CTLE Services Spotlight for your department, program, school, or college meeting, or a workshop or consultation for your department, or if you have any questions about any of our departmental supports or services or would like to arrange a one-on-one consultation about other specific ways the CTLE might support your department, please complete this short form:

Schedule a Consultation


Further Reading: Critical Teaching Behaviors (CTB)

Beyond the Checklist: What Does Good Teaching Look Like? | NEA

Critical Teaching Behaviors

Rethinking Bias in Student Evaluations: A Multivariate Analysis of Observable Instructional Behaviors | Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Ed

Validating the Critical Teaching Behaviors Midterm Feedback Instrument for enhanced teaching effectiveness and student engagement | To Improve the Academy: A Journal of Educational Development


Further Reading: Peer Observations of Teaching

Peer Observation of Teaching | University of Chicago Center for Teaching and Learning

Peer Observations of Teaching | Purdue University Center for Faculty Excellence

Peer Observation of Teaching | Elon University Center for the Advancement of Teaching and Learning

Peer Review of Teaching | Agile Learning

Reclaiming Peer Observation as a Compassionate Community Practice | Wonkhe